Shops sell ready-made gift baskets with a good selection of produce or flowers, but they also sell the baskets themselves – so you can make one yourself. The question is what to put in it.

Start with a theme

The single thing that separates a good basket from a collection of items.

A theme gives the contents a reason to be together, and the whole reads as considered. A basket of assorted nice things reads as leftovers, however good each item is.

Good themes: coffee or tea, baking, gardening, film night, a new home, a new baby, pampering, a particular cuisine.

Build around one good thing

One item genuinely worth having, then smaller things supporting it.

A good bag of coffee, then a mug, a biscuit, a small jar of something. The anchor item sets the perceived quality of the whole basket, so the supporting items need not be expensive.

This is also how to control cost: one decent thing plus five modest ones looks better than six mediocre ones.

Mix the types of thing

A basket of only food is a hamper. A good gift basket mixes categories.

Something consumable, something lasting, something handmade, and something small and unexpected. That mix is what makes it feel thought about.

Include something handmade

What turns a bought basket into a personal gift.

A crocheted dishcloth in a kitchen basket. A knitted mug cosy with the coffee. Homemade biscuits, jam or a spice blend. A hand-written tag.

One handmade element changes how the whole thing reads.

The container counts

And it should be usable afterwards. A basket, a wooden crate, a mixing bowl, a plant pot, a tin, a tote bag.

A container that gets kept extends the gift; one that goes in the recycling is money spent on packaging.

Assembling it

Fill the base with crumpled paper or a folded tea towel, or everything sinks and it looks half empty.

Height at the back, smaller items forward, so everything is visible.

Labels facing out. Obvious and routinely forgotten.

Wrap in cellophane and tie, or leave open with a ribbon.

At any budget

A themed basket works at any price. A tea, a charity-shop mug, homemade shortbread and a knitted cosy costs very little and looks generous.

The theme and the presentation do the work, not the spending.