Two versions of the same chunky winter hat – one crocheted, one knitted – both designed around a single 250 yard skein of bulky weight yarn. Bulky yarn is what makes these fast: the stitches are large, the fabric grows quickly, and either version is realistically an evening’s work.
The crochet version
250 yards of bulky weight yarn and a US size M/13 (9mm) hook.
The knit version
250 yards of bulky weight yarn, US size 13 (9mm) double-pointed needles and a 16 inch circular needle. The circular needle carries the body of the hat; the double-pointed needles take over at the crown when the stitch count drops too low to go round the cable.
Sizing
One size fits most. The finished circumference is approximately 22 inches when stretched, with a height of 9 inches including a 3 inch fold-up brim.
That stretched measurement matters. A hat should measure an inch or two less than the head it is going on so that it grips; knitted and crocheted fabric relaxes with wear, and a hat that fits exactly when new will be sliding over someone’s eyes by February.
Which one to make
The knitted version produces a stretchier, closer-fitting fabric that hugs the head. The crocheted version is thicker and warmer for the same yarn, with more structure to the brim. Neither is harder than the other – pick whichever craft you are faster at, or make both and compare.
Yarn notes
Bulky weight covers a fairly wide range, so check your gauge rather than trusting the label alone. Wool or a wool blend will be warmer than acrylic; acrylic will survive being left in a coat pocket and put through the wash, which for a hat is a genuine consideration.
